THE FISHERMEN,THE FOOL & A VISITOR FROM THE STARS
An exceedingly unlikely afternoon with William Shakespeare, Mark Twain, and a rather inquisitive Grey Alien.
A tale of words, wisdom, worlds, and the peculiar human talent for making an almighty mess of absolutely everything.
CHAPTER ONE
Two Gentlemen, One River, and Not a Fish Between Them
It was a beautiful afternoon.
Not merely beautiful in the ordinary sense, but one of those rare English summer afternoons when the heavens appear to have forgotten their usual obligation to rain upon everything.
The sky was an exquisite blue.
The sun warmed the rolling green hills.
A gentle breeze wandered through the ancient willow trees, disturbing their branches just enough to make them whisper.
The river moved lazily through the countryside, carrying reflections of clouds, trees, and the occasional unfortunate insect towards destinations unknown.
Birds sang.
Bees hummed.
Somewhere in the distance, a cow expressed an opinion.
And sitting beside the river were two gentlemen who, between them, had written enough words to fill several libraries, offended countless respectable citizens, amused millions, and continued to cause trouble long after their respective deaths.
William Shakespeare.
And Samuel Langhorne Clemens.
Better known to the world as Mark Twain.
Quite how these two gentlemen had arrived at the same riverbank, on the same afternoon, several centuries removed from their natural lifetimes, is a question best left unanswered.
After all, if eternity cannot accommodate a little creative scheduling, what exactly is the point of it?
Shakespeare sat upon a small wooden stool.
He wore dark Elizabethan breeches, stockings, polished shoes, an embroidered doublet, and a collar so elaborate that it looked as though a particularly ambitious laundress had attempted to construct a wedding cake around his neck.
Beside him stood a wicker basket containing bread, cheese, two apples, and a bottle of excellent red wine.
His fishing rod extended gracefully over the water.
He had been watching its motionless float for almost an hour.
Mark Twain, meanwhile, had made himself comfortable beneath a magnificent willow tree.
He wore his familiar white suit.
A cigar rested between his fingers.
His fishing rod was propped against a forked branch, while its owner appeared considerably more interested in the contents of a silver flask.
"William," Twain announced, "I've reached a conclusion."
Shakespeare sighed.
"Another?"
"Yes."
"Pray, enlighten me."
"Fishing is the finest occupation ever invented by a man who didn't particularly want to work."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Yet there is poetry in the pursuit."
"There's poetry in almost anything if you stare at it long enough. Even a tax collector. Though I wouldn't recommend the experiment."
"Patience, Samuel. Patience is the companion of wisdom."
"Then wisdom must be the most miserable creature alive. I've been patient for two hours and haven't caught so much as a cold."
Shakespeare adjusted his collar.
"Perhaps the fish are contemplating their destiny."
"Perhaps they've heard we're here."
A kingfisher flashed across the water.
Shakespeare watched it admiringly.
"Behold! Nature's living jewel."
Twain took another puff of his cigar.
"That's a bird that understands fishing. No expensive equipment, no elaborate theories, and no need to discuss destiny with its dinner."
For several minutes they sat in companionable silence.
Then Shakespeare spoke.
"Samuel, do you ever wonder whether mankind shall eventually learn to live in peace?"
Twain considered the question.
"Certainly."
"I imagine it'll happen shortly after mankind learns to keep its mouth shut."
"Such pessimism."
"Experience, William. Experience. Pessimism is merely optimism that has read the newspaper."
Shakespeare laughed.
"You have little faith in our fellow men."
"On the contrary. I have enormous faith in their ability to disappoint me. They've never once let me down."
At that precise moment, something extraordinary happened.
On the opposite bank of the river, the air began to shimmer.
Not violently.
Not dramatically.
There was no thunder, no lightning, no heavenly trumpet, and certainly no choir of angels.
Instead, the atmosphere appeared to fold gently inward, rather like a silk handkerchief being drawn through an invisible ring.
A small figure materialised beneath an oak tree.
Four feet tall.
Grey skin.
An unusually large head.
Long, slender arms.
Three elongated fingers and a thumb upon each hand.
A tiny mouth.
Almost no visible nose.
Two enormous black eyes that seemed to absorb rather than reflect the afternoon sunlight.
The creature stood perfectly still.
It looked at Shakespeare.
Then Twain.
Then the river.
Then the fishing rods.
Then Shakespeare again.
Finally, it spoke.
"Who are you?"
Shakespeare rose immediately.
A lifetime in the theatre had taught him never to waste an entrance.
"Good afternoon, strange traveller!
I am William Shakespeare, poet, playwright, and humble servant of the English tongue."
The creature blinked.
"Why is your tongue English?"
Twain lowered his cigar.
"William, you've found someone who takes you more literally than your critics."
Shakespeare frowned.
"And you, sir? From whence do you come?"
The creature ignored the question.
It turned towards Twain.
"Who are you?"
"Samuel Clemens."
A pause.
"Also known as Mark Twain."
"Why do you have two names?"
"Because one wasn't sufficient to contain all my troubles."
The creature considered this.
"Are you two separate beings?"
"Only when my wife was angry with me."
The Grey stared.
Twain smiled.
"William, I believe we've found someone who's going to require a great deal of explanation."
The creature looked at the fishing rods.
"What are you doing?"
"Fishing," replied Shakespeare.
"Why?"
Twain raised his flask.
"Now there's a question I've been asking myself for forty years."
"What is fishing?"
"The art of persuading an innocent creature to eat something that will ruin its afternoon."
"Why would you do that?"
"Because we are human."
The Grey considered this answer.
Then asked the question that would change the entire afternoon.
"What is human?"
Twain looked at Shakespeare.
Shakespeare looked at Twain.
Somewhere downstream, a trout jumped.
Neither gentleman noticed.
"Well," Twain said slowly, "this could take a while."
CHAPTER TWO
A Visitor Who Had Never Heard a Story
The Grey remained standing on the opposite bank.
Shakespeare, ever the gracious host, gestured towards a small wooden footbridge a short distance upstream.
"Come, good sir. Cross the bridge and join us."
The creature turned its enormous eyes towards the bridge.
"Why?"
"Because we cannot properly converse while shouting across a river."
"Why not?"
"Because," Twain interrupted, "William enjoys hearing himself speak, and I enjoy interrupting him. It's a complicated arrangement."
The Grey looked down at the water.
Then, without the slightest movement of its limbs, rose gently into the air.
It floated across the river.
Descended beside Shakespeare.
And stood silently upon the grass.
Twain removed his cigar.
"Well, I'll be damned."
Shakespeare stared.
"By what sorcery is this accomplished?"
The Grey tilted its head.
"What is sorcery?"
Twain replaced his cigar.
"William, we're going to need a bigger afternoon."
The Grey examined Shakespeare's clothing.
"Why are you wearing that?"
"These are the garments of my age."
"How old are you?"
Shakespeare hesitated.
"That depends upon whether you count the years since my birth, my death, or my arrival here."
"Why did you die?"
"Because all men must."
"Why?"
Twain waved his cigar.
"Now, there's another question we'd be grateful if you could answer."
The Grey regarded them both.
"You are biological organisms of limited duration."
"That," said Twain, "is the most depressing description of humanity I've ever heard. And I've attended funerals."
The creature looked at Shakespeare.
"What is a funeral?"
"A gathering to honour one who has departed this life."
"Why gather?"
"To remember."
"Why remember?"
"Because we loved them."
"What is love?"
Shakespeare opened his mouth.
Closed it.
Opened it again.
Twain watched with considerable amusement.
"Careful, William. You've written enough about that subject to sink a battleship."
Shakespeare placed one hand upon his chest.
"Love, dear visitor, is the force that binds souls beyond the limitations of time, distance, and mortality."
The Grey remained motionless.
"Define soul."
Twain burst out laughing.
"William, you're being taken apart faster than a cheap umbrella in a thunderstorm."
The Grey turned towards him.
"Why are you making that noise?"
"Laughter."
"Why?"
"Because something is funny."
"What is funny?"
Twain slowly lowered his cigar.
"Good Lord."
Shakespeare smiled.
"At last, Samuel. A creature upon whom your wit is entirely wasted."
Twain considered the Grey.
"Tell me, little fellow, where exactly do you come from?"
The creature looked upwards.
"Far."
"How far?"
"Beyond your visible stars."
"That's a considerable distance to travel merely to spoil a fishing trip."
"I did not come for fishing."
"Then why are you here?"
The Grey paused.
"To investigate an anomaly."
Shakespeare raised an eyebrow.
"What anomaly?"
"You."
Twain looked delighted.
"William, we're officially an anomaly. I always suspected it."
The Grey continued.
"My civilization has studied your species for a very long time. Your behaviour is contradictory. Your development is irregular. Your collective decisions are frequently destructive."
Twain nodded.
"An excellent summary. You should run for Congress."
"What is Congress?"
"A collection of individuals who gather to discuss problems they have little intention of solving."
"Why?"
"Because the alternative would be to solve them."
The Grey looked at Shakespeare.
"Is this true?"
Shakespeare smiled diplomatically.
"Samuel has a somewhat colourful interpretation of public affairs."
"Meaning," Twain replied, "that I have actually observed them."
The Grey approached the wicker basket.
It examined the bread.
"What is this?"
"Bread."
"Why?"
"To eat."
"Why?"
"To sustain the body."
The creature looked at Shakespeare's wine.
"And this?"
"Wine."
"Why?"
Twain grinned.
"To make sustaining the body more tolerable."
The Grey regarded them with increasing fascination.
"You consume biological matter. You require liquids. You experience discomfort. You age. You die. You cannot communicate without producing sounds."
"That about covers it," said Twain.
"And yet you have produced something my civilisation cannot explain."
Shakespeare leaned forward.
"What might that be?"
The Grey looked directly into his eyes.
"Writing."
A silence followed.
Then Shakespeare smiled.
"Writing?"
"Yes."
Twain chuckled.
"Well, William, now you've done it. The universe has finally come looking for an explanation."
CHAPTER THREE
What Is Writing?
Shakespeare settled himself upon his stool.
The Grey sat cross-legged upon the grass.
Twain remained beneath the willow, looking rather pleased that the conversation had finally wandered into territory where he could be troublesome.
"Writing," Shakespeare began, "is the art of giving form to thought."
The Grey considered this.
"Why must thought have form?"
"That it may be shared."
"Why not share the thought directly?"
"Because we cannot enter another's mind."
The Grey tilted its head.
"Why not?"
Twain raised a finger.
"Before you ask another question, perhaps you'd better tell us how your people communicate."
"Through direct transmission of consciousness."
Shakespeare stared.
"Telepathy?"
"If that is your word."
"Then you require no speech?"
"Speech is inefficient."
Twain nodded.
"On that point, we agree entirely."
The Grey continued.
"Information is transferred directly. No ambiguity. No interpretation. No misunderstanding."
Shakespeare looked troubled.
"No misunderstanding?"
"Correct."
"No double meanings?"
"No."
"No metaphors?"
"What is metaphor?"
Twain sat upright.
"William, this is worse than I thought."
Shakespeare leaned forward.
"A metaphor is the comparison of one thing with another, that understanding may be deepened through imagination."
"Why compare unlike things?"
"Because," Shakespeare replied, "sometimes truth is best revealed through what is not literally true."
The Grey stared.
"That is contradictory."
"Indeed."
"Why deliberately communicate something untrue?"
"Because a thing may be false in fact yet true in meaning."
The creature remained silent.
Twain intervened.
"Suppose I tell you that a certain politician has the brain of a turnip."
"Is the politician's brain composed of vegetable tissue?"
"No."
"Then your statement is false."
"Scientifically, yes. Politically, it's probably generous."
Shakespeare laughed.
The Grey did not.
Twain sighed.
"We've got our work cut out for us."
Shakespeare picked up a small twig.
Upon a patch of damp earth, he wrote:
LOVE
The Grey examined the four letters.
"What is that?"
"A word."
"Why?"
"It represents an idea."
"Why not transmit the idea?"
"Because, dear visitor, when I write this word, another may read it long after I am gone."
"Why is that important?"
Shakespeare's expression softened.
"Because the body dies, but words may endure."
The Grey looked at the letters.
"Then writing is a method of preserving consciousness?"
"In part."
"An external memory?"
"Yes."
"A defence against death?"
Shakespeare became very still.
Twain watched him.
Finally, the playwright spoke.
"Perhaps that is precisely what it is."
The Grey touched the damp earth.
"Then your species writes because it fears extinction."
Twain shook his head.
"Not entirely. We also write because we have something to say."
"Why?"
"Because nobody listens."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Because the human heart contains more than one lifetime can express."
The Grey looked between them.
"What is a heart?"
Twain pointed to his chest.
"A rather unreliable pump that human beings insist upon blaming for their worst decisions."
Shakespeare ignored him.
"The heart is where we imagine our deepest feelings reside."
"But feelings originate in biological processes."
"Perhaps," said Shakespeare.
"Yet knowing the machinery of a thing does not explain its meaning."
The Grey considered this carefully.
"Explain."
Shakespeare looked towards the river.
"Can you measure the water?"
"Yes."
"Can you determine its depth?"
"Yes."
"Its speed?"
"Yes."
"Its chemical composition?"
"Yes."
"Can you explain why the sight of it brings peace to a troubled soul?"
The Grey paused.
"Peace is a neurological state."
"Then why," Shakespeare asked gently,
"does the same river comfort one man and remind another of the child he lost beneath its waters?"
For the first time, the Grey did not immediately reply.
Twain smiled.
"Careful, little fellow. William's just introduced you to poetry. It's been confusing sensible people for centuries."
The Grey stared at the river.
"Your species assigns different meanings to identical physical objects."
"Precisely," said Shakespeare.
"That is inefficient."
"That," replied Twain, "is humanity."
CHAPTER FOUR
The Curious Business of Being Human
The Grey remained silent for several minutes.
Then it asked:
"Why are humans so different from one another?"
Twain laughed.
"Because nature has a sense of humour."
Shakespeare considered the question more seriously.
"Because each life is a unique experience."
"But you share the same biological structure."
"More or less," Twain replied. "Though I've encountered several men whose heads appeared to contain nothing but furniture."
The Grey ignored him.
"If you are fundamentally similar, why do you disagree?"
Shakespeare smiled.
"Because we see the world through different eyes."
"Yet your eyes function similarly."
Twain groaned.
"William, explain perspective before I throw myself into the river."
Shakespeare gestured towards the ancient oak across the water.
"Look upon that tree."
The Grey obeyed.
"What do you see?"
"A biological organism. Approximately two hundred years old.
Its structure is composed primarily of carbon-based cellular material."
"Very good. Samuel?"
Twain examined the oak.
"I see a splendid place to sit beneath while avoiding honest employment."
Shakespeare nodded.
" I see a living monument to time. A witness to generations.
A creature whose roots embrace the earth while its branches reach towards heaven."
The Grey looked from one to the other.
"All three descriptions refer to the same object."
"Indeed."
"Yet they are different."
"Exactly."
"Which is correct?"
Shakespeare smiled.
"All of them."
The Grey appeared genuinely unsettled.
"How can multiple interpretations be correct?"
Twain tapped the side of his nose.
"Welcome to Earth, where everyone is certain they're right and half the trouble begins there."
The Grey looked thoughtful.
"Your species appears to confuse interpretation with truth."
Twain nodded.
"Frequently."
"Does this cause conflict?"
"Constantly."
"Violence?"
"Regrettably."
"War?"
Shakespeare lowered his gaze.
"Yes."
The Grey looked at both men.
"Why?"
Twain exhaled slowly.
"Now, there's the question that has kept humanity busy since the first fellow discovered he could hit his neighbour with a rock."
"Why would he strike his neighbour?"
"Because his neighbour possessed something he wanted."
"What?"
"Land. Food. Wealth. Power. A better-looking wife. Take your pick."
"Could he not ask?"
"He could."
"Could they not share?"
"They could."
"Then why fight?"
Twain looked at Shakespeare.
"William, you explain this one. You've written enough tragedies about it."
Shakespeare gazed towards the distant hills.
"Because mankind is afflicted with a peculiar blindness.
He sees what another possesses more clearly than what he himself enjoys."
The Grey considered this.
"Envy."
"Yes."
"Greed."
"Yes."
"Fear."
"Very often."
"Then humans are controlled by primitive impulses."
Twain nodded.
"With astonishingly expensive machinery."
The Grey looked confused.
"Explain."
"We've invented devices capable of travelling beyond our atmosphere, machines that can examine the smallest particles of matter, and instruments that allow us to communicate across oceans."
"Impressive."
"And yet," Twain continued, "we still cannot reliably persuade two grown men
to agree about who owns a patch of dirt."
The Grey tilted its head.
"Your technological development exceeds your emotional development."
Shakespeare looked at Twain.
Twain looked at Shakespeare.
"Well," Twain said, "there's a sentence that ought to be carved above the entrance to every parliament on Earth."
CHAPTER FIVE
A World Without Lies
"Tell us of your people," Shakespeare requested.
The Grey turned towards him.
"What do you wish to know?"
"Everything."
"That would require considerable time."
Twain waved his flask.
"We're fishing. Time is the one thing we've got plenty of."
The Grey looked towards the sky.
"My civilisation exists upon a world orbiting a star beyond your present knowledge."
"Is it beautiful?" asked Shakespeare.
"Define beautiful."
Twain sighed.
"Here we go again."
Shakespeare smiled patiently.
"Does your world possess oceans?
Mountains?
Forests? Creatures that sing?"
"Yes."
"Then surely it possesses beauty."
"Beauty is a subjective evaluation."
"Naturally."
"Subjectivity is unreliable."
"Yet it is the foundation of art."
The Grey considered this.
"We have no art."
Shakespeare froze.
"No art?"
"Correct."
"No paintings?"
"No."
"No music?"
"We utilize organized sound for functional purposes."
"No poetry?"
"No."
"No theatre?"
"What is theatre?"
Twain slowly removed his cigar.
"William, I think we've discovered the saddest place in the universe."
The Grey looked puzzled.
"Our civilisation is peaceful.
Disease has been eliminated.
Hunger is unknown.
Material resources are distributed according to need.
Violence is almost nonexistent."
Shakespeare leaned forward.
"Then you have accomplished much that humanity has only dreamed of."
"Yes."
"Do your people love?"
"We maintain biological and social bonds."
"Do they marry?"
"Partnerships are formed according to compatibility."
"Do they quarrel?"
"Rarely."
"Do they deceive one another?"
"No."
Twain sat upright.
"Hold on."
The Grey looked at him.
"You never lie?"
"Correct."
"Not even a little?"
"No."
"Not to spare someone's feelings?"
"No."
"Not to avoid embarrassment?"
"No."
"Not to escape responsibility?"
"No."
Twain stared.
"Then how on Earth do you conduct politics?"
"We do not."
Shakespeare laughed.
Twain looked delighted.
"William, we've finally found a civilisation worth visiting."
The Grey continued.
"Decisions are reached through collective assessment of available evidence."
Twain's expression became almost reverential.
"Collective assessment of evidence?"
"Yes."
"And your leaders accept the results?"
"We have no leaders in the human sense."
"Good heavens."
"Authority is assigned temporarily according to competence."
Twain stood.
"William, pack the basket. We're emigrating."
Shakespeare raised a hand.
"Patience, Samuel."
"Patience? These people have managed to eliminate politicians!"
The Grey tilted its head.
"Why do humans permit incompetent individuals to govern them?"
Twain slowly sat down again.
"That's a question which, if answered honestly,
could bring down half the governments on Earth."
Shakespeare considered the matter.
"Perhaps because men are often more easily persuaded by confidence than wisdom."
"Explain."
Twain answered.
"A fool who shouts loudly enough can convince a thousand people he's a genius.
A wise man who speaks softly may struggle to convince ten."
The Grey looked troubled.
"Then your species rewards volume rather than accuracy."
"Frequently."
"That is irrational."
"Yes."
"Why continue?"
Twain smiled sadly.
"Because, little fellow, admitting we've been fooled is often harder than continuing to be fooled."
For several moments, the Grey said nothing.
Then it asked:
"Do humans know they are being deceived?"
"Sometimes."
"They accept it?"
"Sometimes."
"Why?"
Shakespeare answered quietly.
"Because truth can be painful, while a comforting falsehood may feel like shelter."
The Grey looked down at the word LOVE, still written in the earth.
"Then perhaps your species requires writing because it cannot trust speech."
Twain considered that.
"There's more truth in that observation than I'd care to admit."
CHAPTER SIX
The Most Dangerous Invention in Human History
The Grey looked towards the distant hills.
"Your civilisation possesses weapons capable of destroying its own habitat."
Twain nodded.
"Several times over."
"Why?"
"Because apparently destroying the world once wasn't considered sufficient insurance."
Shakespeare shook his head.
"Samuel."
"What?"
"Must you jest about everything?"
"Not everything. Just the things that would otherwise make me weep."
The Grey regarded Twain closely.
"Humour is a method of concealing distress."
Twain smiled.
"Sometimes. It's also a useful way of telling the truth without getting immediately arrested."
The Grey continued.
"Why do humans manufacture weapons of mass destruction?"
"Fear," Shakespeare replied.
"Of what?"
"One another."
"Then why not establish mutual understanding?"
Twain chuckled bitterly.
"Because understanding requires listening, and listening is considerably less fashionable than shouting."
The Grey considered this.
"Your species devotes enormous resources to preparing for conflicts it claims to wish to avoid."
"Correct."
"While other members of your species lack food."
"Correct."
"Water."
"Correct."
"Shelter."
"Correct."
"Medical care."
Twain said nothing.
The Grey's enormous eyes moved between the two men.
"Explain."
Shakespeare lowered his head.
Twain extinguished his cigar.
For once, the American humourist seemed unable to find a joke.
Finally, he spoke.
"We have become remarkably clever at calculating the cost of everything except human suffering."
The Grey waited.
Twain continued.
"We can calculate how much it costs to build a weapon. How much it costs to launch it. How much it costs to replace it. We can even calculate how much destruction it will cause."
"And the suffering?"
"We put that in a different column."
"Why?"
"Because if we put it in the same column, we might have to stop."
Shakespeare looked towards the water.
"There is a terrible contradiction within mankind. We possess the capacity for extraordinary kindness, yet so often surrender ourselves to cruelty."
The Grey tilted its head.
"Why?"
"Because," Shakespeare replied, "we have not yet learned to govern our own appetites."
The Grey considered this.
"Then your greatest danger is not your weapons."
Twain looked up.
"What is it?"
"Your inability to control the minds that create them."
A long silence followed.
Somewhere nearby, a blackbird began to sing.
Twain stared at the Grey.
"Little fellow, you're beginning to sound like a writer."
"What is a writer?"
"Someone who notices what everyone else is trying very hard not to see."
The Grey appeared to consider this a compliment.
It wasn't entirely sure why.
CHAPTER SEVEN
God, Heaven, and the Administrative Difficulties of Eternity
Shakespeare poured himself another glass of wine.
"Tell me, friend. Do your people believe in God?"
The Grey looked at him.
"Define God."
Twain groaned.
"William, you've opened a door we may never get closed."
Shakespeare ignored him.
"The creator of all things."
"Which things?"
"Everything."
"All matter?"
"Yes."
"All energy?"
"Yes."
"All consciousness?"
"Yes."
"All universes?"
Shakespeare hesitated.
"Universes?"
The Grey nodded.
"Plural."
Twain slowly lowered his flask.
"William, I believe the universe has just become considerably more crowded."
The Grey continued.
"Your species has developed thousands of religious systems."
"Indeed," Shakespeare replied.
"Many claim exclusive access to universal truth."
"Regrettably."
"Yet their claims frequently contradict one another."
"Yes."
"Why?"
Twain smiled.
"Because humanity has never been satisfied with merely believing something.
We generally insist that everyone else believe it too."
The Grey tilted its head.
"Why?"
"Because doubt is uncomfortable."
"Then belief is a defence against uncertainty?"
"Sometimes."
Shakespeare raised a finger.
"Yet faith may also inspire kindness, courage, charity, and extraordinary sacrifice."
"Certainly," Twain agreed.
"The trouble begins when someone decides his faith entitles him to manage everybody else's."
The Grey considered this.
"Do your religious systems encourage peace?"
"Many do," Shakespeare replied.
"Then why have humans fought wars in their names?"
Twain stared at the river.
"Because humans possess a remarkable ability to read a message
about love and conclude that somebody needs killing."
Shakespeare winced.
"Samuel!"
"What? It's true."
The Grey looked puzzled.
"Does your creator instruct you to destroy one another?"
"Different people claim different instructions," Shakespeare replied carefully.
"Has the creator communicated directly with all of them?"
"No."
"Then how do they verify the instructions?"
Twain burst out laughing.
"William, if this fellow ever visits a theological college, there'll be a riot before lunchtime."
The Grey continued.
"Do humans know what happens after death?"
Shakespeare looked thoughtful.
"We possess beliefs, hopes, traditions, and stories."
"But knowledge?"
"Not certainty."
"Then why do so many speak with certainty?"
Twain smiled.
"Because 'I don't know' is the three-word sentence humanity finds hardest to pronounce."
The Grey fell silent.
Then asked:
"Do you fear death?"
Shakespeare looked at the river.
"I fear leaving things unfinished."
Twain nodded.
"I fear leaving the world in the hands of people who think they know everything."
The Grey considered both answers.
"Neither of you fears nonexistence?"
Shakespeare smiled.
"Perhaps death is not nonexistence."
Twain raised his flask.
"Perhaps it is. Either way, I see no sense in wasting a perfectly good afternoon worrying about it."
The Grey looked at the wine.
"Does that liquid assist with uncertainty?"
"Enormously," said Twain.
CHAPTER EIGHT
The World That Forgot How to Dream
The afternoon had begun to soften.
The sunlight turned golden.
Long shadows stretched across the grass.
The river, indifferent to philosophy, continued its ancient journey towards the sea.
Shakespeare watched the Grey carefully.
"Friend, you have asked us many questions."
"Yes."
"Yet you have told us little of why you came."
The creature remained motionless.
Twain leaned forward.
"He's right. You've travelled across heaven knows how many light-years to interrogate two old fishermen. That seems a considerable expenditure of effort."
The Grey looked down.
For the first time, its posture seemed almost weary.
"My civilization is approaching extinction."
Shakespeare's expression changed.
"From war?"
"No."
"Disease?"
"No."
"Environmental destruction?"
"No."
Twain frowned.
"Then what?"
The Grey looked towards the sky.
"We have ceased to imagine."
Neither man spoke.
The creature continued.
"Long ago, my people possessed creativity. We created images.
Sounds. Stories. We imagined futures that did not yet exist."
"What happened?" Shakespeare asked.
"We perfected our systems."
"Explain."
"We eliminated uncertainty wherever possible. We developed methods of predicting outcomes.
We removed unnecessary emotional disturbances. We replaced subjective judgement with collective calculation."
Twain nodded slowly.
"Sounds efficient."
"It was."
"And?"
"Eventually, there were no unanswered practical questions."
Shakespeare stared.
"No unanswered questions?"
"None that affected our daily existence."
Twain shook his head.
"That sounds less like paradise and more like a very expensive prison."
The Grey continued.
"Our civilisation became stable. Peaceful. Predictable."
"And unhappy?" Shakespeare asked.
The Grey hesitated.
"We no longer understood happiness."
A silence followed.
"Nor sadness. Nor wonder. Nor longing.
Our population began to decline. Not through illness or catastrophe,
but because fewer individuals wished to create new life."
Twain looked troubled.
"Why?"
"Because they could imagine no reason to do so."
Shakespeare slowly rose from his stool.
"My dear friend."
The Grey looked up.
"Yes?"
"You have not lost the ability to survive."
"No."
"You have lost the desire to live."
The Grey remained silent.
Then, very softly, it replied.
"Yes."
For the first time that afternoon,
Twain did not reach for his cigar.
The Grey continued.
"We have searched many worlds. Studied countless civilisations. But your species is unique."
"Unique?" Shakespeare repeated.
"You suffer. You fail. You make mistakes.
You destroy what you love. You know that you will die."
Twain nodded.
"A charming introduction."
"Yet you continue to imagine."
The Grey looked directly at Shakespeare.
"You create people who never existed."
Then at Twain.
"You describe journeys you never made."
It looked between them.
"You construct worlds from symbols. You experience grief for imaginary beings.
You laugh at events that never occurred. You preserve the thoughts of the dead."
Shakespeare's eyes softened.
The Grey continued.
"Your species possesses almost no certainty about its future."
"True," Twain replied.
"Yet you continue to dream of it."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Because hope requires no guarantee."
The Grey looked at him.
"Explain hope."
Twain leaned forward.
"Hope, little fellow, is what keeps a man fishing when the fish
have clearly decided to spend the afternoon elsewhere."
Shakespeare laughed.
"An inelegant definition."
"But accurate."
The Grey looked at the fishing rods.
"Then fishing is an exercise in hope?"
Twain considered this.
"Well, I'll be damned. Perhaps it is."
The creature sat silently.
Then asked:
"Can hope be taught?"
Shakespeare looked at Twain.
Twain looked at Shakespeare.
Neither answered immediately.
Finally, Shakespeare spoke.
"Perhaps not taught in the manner of arithmetic. But it may be awakened."
"How?"
"Through stories."
The Grey looked at the word LOVE in the earth.
"Then I must learn to write."
CHAPTER NINE
The First Story Ever Told by a Grey
Twain stood.
"Well, William, it appears we've been promoted."
"To what?"
"Teachers."
Shakespeare smiled.
"A noble calling."
"Possibly. Though I suspect our student may be more difficult than most."
The Grey looked up.
"What must I do?"
Shakespeare knelt beside the patch of damp earth.
"First, you must understand that a story is not merely a record of events."
"What is it?"
"A journey."
"To where?"
"Somewhere that may not exist."
The Grey looked confused.
"Why travel somewhere nonexistent?"
Twain smiled.
"Because sometimes the places that don't exist teach us more about the places that do."
Shakespeare nodded.
"Precisely."
The Grey considered this.
"Then give me an example."
Shakespeare thought for a moment.
"Imagine a king."
"What is a king?"
Twain groaned.
"William, start with something simpler.
At this rate we'll still be here when the sun burns out."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Very well. Imagine a small creature."
"What kind?"
"Any kind."
"Specify."
"A bird."
"Which species?"
"A sparrow."
"Age?"
Twain threw up his hands.
"Good heavens! It's like trying to tell a bedtime story to an accountant."
Shakespeare persisted.
"Imagine a sparrow who wishes to fly beyond the stars."
The Grey stared.
"That is biologically impossible."
"Indeed."
"Then the story is false."
"Not necessarily."
"Explain."
"The sparrow represents longing. Its journey represents aspiration.
The stars represent the unknown."
The Grey considered this.
"Then the story is not about a sparrow."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Exactly."
Twain clapped his hands.
"He's learning!"
The Grey looked towards the river.
"May I attempt a story?"
"By all means," Shakespeare replied.
The creature sat very still.
Then spoke.
"There was once a being who lived upon a world where everything was known."
Twain nodded encouragingly.
"Go on."
"The being was not unhappy, because unhappiness had been eliminated."
Shakespeare listened intently.
"But one day, the being discovered an unanswered question."
"What question?" Shakespeare whispered.
The Grey looked at him.
"Why?"
Twain smiled.
"An excellent beginning."
"The being asked the question of its companions. They could not answer.
So it travelled beyond its world."
The Grey paused.
"It visited many places. It encountered many forms of life.
But none could explain why the question mattered."
Shakespeare leaned forward.
"Then?"
"It arrived upon a small blue planet."
Twain grinned.
"Sounds familiar."
"There it encountered two primitive biological organisms beside a river."
"Primitive?" Twain protested. "William, I think we've just been insulted."
The Grey continued.
"The organisms were engaged in an activity that produced no measurable result."
"Fishing," Shakespeare whispered.
"Yes."
"They were not distressed by their failure. Instead, they appeared content."
The Grey paused.
"One spoke of beauty. The other spoke of foolishness.
Both spoke of things that could not be measured."
Shakespeare's eyes glistened.
"What did the traveller learn?"
The Grey looked at the river.
"That perhaps a question does not need an answer to possess value."
A long silence followed.
Then Twain slowly stood.
He removed his hat.
"William."
"Yes, Samuel?"
"I believe our little friend has just written his first story."
Shakespeare rose.
He bowed deeply towards the Grey.
"A very fine story it is."
The creature stared.
"Why are you bending?"
Twain burst out laughing.
"Because, little fellow, you've just earned something that can't be calculated."
"What?"
"Respect."
CHAPTER TEN
The Price of Perfection
The Grey remained seated, looking at the little word Shakespeare had written in the earth.
LOVE.
Four letters.
A concept that had confused philosophers, inspired poets, toppled kingdoms, launched ships, started wars, ended feuds, and persuaded otherwise sensible individuals to behave like complete idiots.
"Your species is contradictory," the Grey said at last.
Twain nodded.
"We've established that."
"You possess imagination, yet you frequently use it to invent new methods of destruction."
"True."
"You possess compassion, yet permit suffering."
"True."
"You possess intelligence, yet repeatedly ignore evidence."
"Painfully true."
"You create laws intended to establish justice, yet allow wealth and power to influence their application."
Twain looked at Shakespeare.
"William, I believe he's been reading the newspapers."
The Grey continued.
"Why do you not correct these contradictions?"
Shakespeare considered the question.
"Because recognising a fault and overcoming it are very different achievements."
"Why?"
"Because men are not governed by reason alone."
The Grey tilted its head.
"Then perhaps humanity should eliminate emotion."
Twain sat bolt upright.
"No!"
The creature looked startled.
"Why not?"
"Because you'd eliminate half of what makes us worth saving."
"Emotion causes suffering."
"So does ignorance," Twain replied. "We don't cure ignorance by removing the brain."
The Grey considered this.
"Emotion produces conflict."
"Yes."
"Jealousy."
"Yes."
"Hatred."
"Yes."
"Violence."
"Sometimes."
"Then why preserve it?"
Shakespeare answered.
"Because emotion also produces tenderness, courage, generosity, wonder, forgiveness, and love."
"These can be reproduced through rational systems."
"Can they?"
"Yes."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Then tell me, friend. If a mother embraces her child because a calculation determines that affection is beneficial,
is that the same as embracing the child because her heart overflows with love?"
The Grey paused.
"The physical action is identical."
"Yet the meaning may differ."
"Meaning is subjective."
"Precisely."
Twain leaned forward.
"You see, little fellow, perfection is a dangerous ambition."
"Why?"
"Because sooner or later somebody has to decide what perfection looks like."
The Grey remained silent.
"Once they decide," Twain continued, "they generally start removing anything that doesn't fit."
Shakespeare nodded.
"The crooked tree. The imperfect face. The unusual mind. The rebellious thought."
"The inconvenient question," Twain added.
"The unexpected dream," said Shakespeare.
The Grey looked down.
"Our civilisation removed uncertainty."
"And with it," Shakespeare replied gently, "perhaps you removed possibility."
The Grey appeared to absorb this.
"Then imperfection has value?"
Twain grinned.
"Certainly. Without imperfection, William would have had no characters to write about, and I'd have had no human beings to make fun of."
Shakespeare laughed.
"And without imagination, Samuel, you would have had no means of making them laugh."
"Exactly."
The Grey considered this.
"Then your species survives through its flaws?"
Shakespeare shook his head.
"Not through its flaws alone. Through its capacity to recognise them, learn from them, and become something better."
Twain nodded.
"Though I wish we'd hurry up about it."
The Grey looked towards the sky.
"Perhaps my people have mistaken the absence of problems for the presence of life."
Shakespeare smiled.
"A profound distinction."
Twain raised his flask.
" That deserves a drink."
The Grey looked at the flask.
"Would consuming that substance improve my understanding?"
Twain considered the question.
"Probably not. But it might make you considerably less concerned about the parts you don't understand."
CHAPTER ELEVEN
The Question Nobody Wanted to Answer
The afternoon was drawing towards evening.
The sky had begun its slow transformation from blue to gold.
A heron stood motionless in the shallows.
A dragonfly hovered above the reeds.
And the three unlikely companions sat beside the river, surrounded by questions that no civilisation, however advanced, had ever fully answered.
The Grey looked at Shakespeare.
"May I ask you something?"
"Certainly."
"Why did you write?"
Shakespeare considered the question.
"Because I wished to understand mankind."
"Did you succeed?"
The playwright smiled sadly.
"Not entirely."
"Then why continue?"
"Because every story brought me closer."
The Grey turned towards Twain.
"Why did you write?"
Twain looked at the river.
"Because I saw foolishness everywhere, and it seemed a shame to let it go unrecorded."
"Did your writing eliminate foolishness?"
Twain laughed.
"Not remotely."
"Then why continue?"
"Because occasionally, when a man laughs at his own foolishness, he becomes capable of recognising it."
The Grey considered this.
"Then writing is an attempt to change consciousness."
"Sometimes," Shakespeare replied.
"Does it work?"
"Sometimes."
"Why only sometimes?"
Twain smiled.
"Because people are remarkably skilled at believing that every criticism is intended for somebody else."
The Grey remained silent.
Then asked:
"Do you believe humanity will survive?"
Shakespeare looked troubled.
Twain stared into the distance.
Neither answered immediately.
Finally, Shakespeare spoke.
"I believe mankind possesses the capacity to survive."
"That was not my question."
"No," Shakespeare admitted. "It was not."
The Grey turned towards Twain.
"And you?"
Twain took a long breath.
"I think humanity has two remarkable talents."
"What are they?"
"The ability to create extraordinary problems."
"The second?"
"The ability to solve them when the alternative becomes sufficiently unpleasant."
"Then you are optimistic?"
Twain shook his head.
"I'm hopeful. There's a difference."
"Explain."
"Optimism assumes everything will turn out well. Hope recognises that things may turn out badly, but insists they're still worth improving."
The Grey considered this.
"Then hope requires courage."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Indeed."
"Because the outcome is uncertain."
"Yes."
The creature looked towards the river.
"Then perhaps hope is the most sophisticated form of imagination."
For several moments, neither man spoke.
Then Twain smiled.
"William, he's getting dangerously good at this."
Shakespeare nodded.
"Indeed. Another hour and he'll be writing sonnets."
The Grey tilted its head.
"What is a sonnet?"
Twain groaned.
"Oh, for heaven's sake, don't ask him that. We'll be here until Christmas."
CHAPTER TWELVE
The Gift of an Unanswered Question
The sun was sinking behind the hills.
The Grey rose slowly to its feet.
"I must return."
Shakespeare stood.
"So soon?"
"I have remained longer than intended."
Twain looked at his fishing rod.
"Don't worry. You've missed absolutely nothing."
The Grey looked at the river.
"Have you caught any fish?"
"No," Shakespeare admitted.
"Not one," Twain confirmed.
"Then your activity has failed."
Twain smiled.
"Has it?"
"You intended to catch fish."
"Did we?"
The Grey looked confused.
"That is the stated purpose of fishing."
Shakespeare rose from his stool.
"Perhaps, dear friend, the purpose of an activity is not always the same as its reward."
The Grey considered this.
"Explain."
Shakespeare gestured towards the river.
"We came here to fish."
"Yes."
"Yet we have spent the afternoon discussing life, death, love, war, religion, imagination,
the fate of civilisations."
"Yes."
"We have learned about a world beyond our own."
"Yes."
"Perhaps helped a traveller from that world rediscover something his people had forgotten."
The Grey remained silent.
Twain smiled.
"Not a bad afternoon's work for two fellows who haven't caught dinner."
The creature looked towards the sky.
"I must take something back."
"What?" Shakespeare asked.
"Evidence that imagination has value."
Twain shook his head.
"Evidence won't be enough."
"Why?"
"Because imagination isn't something you can place in a laboratory and measure."
The Grey looked troubled.
"Then how can I demonstrate it?"
Shakespeare smiled.
"Tell them your story."
The creature looked at him.
"My story?"
"Yes."
"But it is incomplete."
"All good stories are."
"Why?"
"Because they continue within the minds of those who hear them."
The Grey considered this.
"Then a story can survive its creator."
"Indeed."
The creature looked down at the word LOVE.
The letters had begun to fade as the damp earth dried.
"May I take that?"
Shakespeare looked puzzled.
"The word?"
"Yes."
Twain smiled.
"Well, William, it appears you've finally found someone willing to take your words literally."
Shakespeare knelt and wrote the four letters again upon a small piece of paper from his basket.
He handed it to the Grey.
"Take this."
The creature examined the paper.
"Four symbols."
"Yes."
"Representing a concept that cannot be precisely defined."
"Yes."
"That produces both joy and suffering."
"Yes."
"That inspires extraordinary acts of kindness and extraordinary acts of foolishness."
Twain nodded.
"Frequently on the same afternoon."
The Grey looked at the paper.
"Then perhaps this is the most complicated word in your language."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Perhaps."
The creature carefully folded the paper.
Then looked at Twain.
"What will you give me?"
Twain considered the question.
He reached into his pocket.
Removed a small notebook.
Tore out a blank page.
Then it to the Grey.
The creature stared.
"There is nothing written upon it."
"Exactly."
"Why give me an empty page?"
Twain smiled.
"Because, little fellow, that's where the next story begins."
The Grey remained perfectly still.
It looked at the word Shakespeare had given it.
Then at Twain's empty page.
Finally, it spoke.
"I understand."
Shakespeare smiled.
"Do you?"
"No."
Twain burst out laughing.
"Then you're making excellent progress!"
The Grey looked at them both.
For a moment, something extraordinary happened.
The corners of its tiny mouth moved.
Very slightly.
Almost imperceptibly.
But unmistakably.
The Grey smiled.
Shakespeare gasped.
Twain stared.
"William."
"Yes?"
"I believe we've just witnessed the first extraterrestrial smile in recorded history."
The Grey touched its mouth.
"What is happening?"
Twain grinned.
"You're learning to be human."
The creature looked alarmed.
"Is that dangerous?"
Twain considered the question.
"Extremely."
EPILOGUE
The One That Got Away
The Grey stepped towards the river.
The air around it began to shimmer.
Shakespeare raised his hand.
"Farewell, strange friend. May your journey be blessed with discovery."
Twain tipped his hat.
"Try not to let your people become too sensible. It's a terrible affliction."
The Grey paused.
"One final question."
Twain sighed.
"Naturally."
"Your species has existed for a very long time."
"Yes."
"You have created extraordinary art, literature, music, science, and philosophy."
"Yes."
"You have discovered the structure of matter, explored the heavens, and developed methods of communicating across your entire planet."
"Yes."
"Yet you continue to fight wars, tolerate hunger, destroy your environment,
permit ignorance to influence your collective decisions."
Twain lowered his hat.
Shakespeare remained silent.
The Grey looked at them both.
"If you are intelligent enough to understand what is wrong,
why are you not intelligent enough to stop doing it?"
The question hung in the evening air.
Neither man answered.
The river continued flowing.
The birds continued singing.
Somewhere beyond the hills, humanity continued being humanity.
Finally, Twain spoke.
"Little fellow, if you ever discover the answer to that question, come back and tell us."
The Grey nodded.
"I shall."
Then it looked towards the fishing rods.
"One more thing."
Twain closed his eyes.
"Good Lord."
"Why have you spent the entire afternoon attempting to capture fish when
you could obtain them more efficiently elsewhere?"
Shakespeare smiled.
"Because fishing teaches patience."
Twain shook his head.
"Because fishing teaches a man that not everything worth doing has to produce something."
The Grey considered both answers.
Then asked:
"May I take a fishing rod?"
Twain looked delighted.
"Certainly!"
He handed the creature his rod.
The Grey examined it.
"A primitive device."
"Extremely."
"Inefficient."
"Completely."
"Unreliable."
"Without question."
"Yet you enjoy using it?"
Twain smiled.
"Immensely."
The Grey looked at the rod.
Then at the river.
Then at Shakespeare.
Then at Twain.
For the second time that afternoon, it smiled.
"I believe I shall introduce fishing to my civilisation."
Shakespeare laughed.
"A noble ambition!"
Twain nodded.
"When they ask what it's for, tell them it's a way of learning to enjoy an afternoon without improving anything."
The Grey held the fishing rod carefully.
Then it stepped backwards.
The air shimmered.
Its outline softened.
With a gentle ripple of light, the visitor vanished.
The riverbank was quiet once more.
Shakespeare sat down.
Twain settled beneath the willow.
For several minutes, neither spoke.
Then Shakespeare looked towards his companion.
"Samuel?"
"Yes, William?"
"Do you believe we have helped him?"
Twain considered the question.
"I believe we've given him something his people have been missing."
"Imagination?"
"Partly."
"Hope?"
"Possibly."
"Then what?"
Twain smiled.
"The freedom to be wrong."
Shakespeare considered this.
"A curious gift."
"The finest gift there is. Without it, nobody ever discovers anything new."
The playwright looked towards the evening sky.
"Do you think he will return?"
Twain relit his cigar.
"Perhaps."
"And if he does?"
"I hope he brings some fish."
Shakespeare laughed.
The sun slipped behind the hills.
The river shimmered in the fading light.
Somewhere, unimaginably far beyond the stars, a small grey creature stood before
the most advanced civilisation in its universe.
In one hand, it held a piece of paper bearing four letters.
LOVE.
In the other, a blank page.
Beside it rested a primitive fishing rod.
The assembled minds of its civilisation regarded these objects with profound confusion.
"What have you brought us?" they asked.
The Grey looked at the paper.
Then at the empty page.
Then at the fishing rod.
And answered:
"The beginning of everything we have forgotten."
"Explain."
The Grey considered the question.
Then, for the first time in the history of its civilization,
it did something entirely unexpected.
It laughed.
And said:
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because I have a story to tell you."
The assembled minds waited.
The Grey looked at the blank page.
Then began.....
"Once upon a time, beside a river on a little blue planet, two extraordinarily foolish creatures
were attempting to catch a fish..."
Somewhere in the universe, something that had been silent for a thousand years began to awaken.
Imagination.
A Final Thought
Perhaps the greatest tragedy of humanity is not that we are imperfect.
Perhaps it is that we spend so much of our existence pretending otherwise.
We build monuments to wisdom while rewarding foolishness.
We celebrate peace while preparing for war.
We praise compassion while tolerating cruelty.
We speak endlessly of truth while finding increasingly sophisticated ways to avoid it.
Yet despite all this, we continue to imagine.
We write stories.
We compose music.
We paint pictures.
We fall in love.
We dream of tomorrow.
So sometimes, just sometimes, we recognize that the world we have created
is not the world we are capable of creating.
Perhaps that is our greatest gift.
Not intelligence.
Not technology.
Not power.
But the ability to look at what exists and imagine what might be.
Perhaps, somewhere beyond the stars, a small grey creature is teaching an entire civilisation that the most important question in existence is not
"What do we know?"
But:
"What if?"
Because every discovery begins with a question.
Every invention begins with an idea.
Every revolution begins with someone imagining that things could be different.
Every story begins with an empty page.
So perhaps, before we congratulate ourselves on being the most intelligent creatures on Earth,
we might consider a rather uncomfortable possibility.
That intelligence without wisdom is merely cleverness.
That knowledge without compassion is merely information.
That power without imagination is simply the ability to make the same mistakes on a much larger scale.
After all, it would be a terrible shame if the first extraterrestrial civilization to visit
Earth discovered that humanity had finally mastered the stars...
But still hadn't learned how to live together beneath them.
As for our two fishermen?
Well, somewhere beside an eternal English river,
Shakespeare and Twain are still sitting beneath the willow trees.
Still arguing.
Still laughing.
Still wondering.
But still haven't caught a bloody fish.
THE END.🎣
For all those who have ever looked up at the stars and wondered whether the universe contains intelligent life.
And for those who occasionally look around Earth and wonder the very same thing.🎣

Comments